Job Ads, False Hope, And Why God Isn’t In Control

For the last few weeks, for various reasons, I’ve been applying for jobs. I’ve applied for a lot of jobs, maybe thirty, and I haven’t gotten a single one of them. Now there’s a few reasons why I think that is, but the reasons why I didn’t get any of these particular jobs isn’t what I want to discuss here and now. Not getting any of these jobs reminds me of a particular job I applied for I didn’t get back in November last year. Not getting that job confused and frustrated me way more than missing out on the most recent thirty or so.

Last November, I resigned from a job as a mental health support worker for reasons of conscience. Certain things were happening to clients, and after a short period of trying to change those things, it became clear I was part of an employment intake required to replace the last lot of troublemakers who thought they could shake up the system. I quit, mainly because I could not in good conscience take money for supporting the conditions under which the clients were living. My high moral ground, however, came at a cost.

That particular job paid good.

I quickly found a position being advertised with another organisation however which actually seemed quite perfect.

Cancer supportive care. Part-time. Close to my home. Reputable non-government agency. I called the organisation and spoke to the person who was hiring. I described my experience to them and asked a few questions about the position. She agreed I seemed very suited and well-qualified for the role, and she encouraged me to submit an application. So I did.

I didn’t even get to interview.

Later, I found out that the role was advertised merely as a formality. Someone was moved into the role from another situation with the same organisation, and there was little if any chance anyone else was ever going to be considered for it.

I was devastated. It had seemed so perfect for me. I really, really wanted that job. I hoped with all my heart I’d get it.

But it was a false hope. What seemed like an amazing opportunity was really just a facade, a series of motions someone else needed to go through in order to keep up appearances on someone else’s behalf.

I’ve often wondered why people and organisations feel they need to do this – offering choice where there really is no choice, giving the impression of opportunity not because an opportunity exists, but because it behooves them to appear like the kind of place or people who provide opportunities. Peddling false hope, implying choice and power and autonomy where there is none, giving the impression of fairness and equity when in fact the outcomes are already decided.

One thing I do know – it feels crappy to be on the receiving end and realise you never really had a chance.


Over the years in certain circumstances people have said to me “God is in control” and I wonder what it is they really mean by this.  Did God know I was going to get cancer? It also begs the deeper question – did He have something to do with it? Was it always going to happen, and was my assumption I would be around to raise my four children to adulthood a kind of false hope? Was my life, my marriage, my family, my career, my relationships up to then just a folly, a playground God had let me fool around in knowing the whole time my life would end at age 35?

My life didn’t end. I survived cancer. But I spent a lot of time when I was sick thinking about why, if God was good and God was in control, He would let me get married and have four children if the whole time I was just going to die of cancer and leave them without a wife a mother.

It got me thinking – does God really know all the outcomes already, and so our free will is merely a patronage on His part? Is God like a parent who asks what we want for lunch when the sandwiches are already made? Does God place tantalising opportunities right where we’ll see them, knowing the whole time someone other than us will get to have all the fun? Does God have certain events set in stone in our lives and no matter what we do, we can’t change them?

Flying in the face of all this predeterminism and fatalism is the wonderful concept of hope.

Hope is the expectation that things can get better than they are right now. It’s the mindset that says yes, things might get worse, or they could improve, and I choose to think about the latter. Hope is tipping the scales in the favour of yes, okay, we will, I can and let’s go. Hope is sometimes the only power we have in a situation to facilitate positive change, and sometimes, is all we have to hold on to. Hope is what happens when we are at the end of our rope, so we unravel the very end of it, and take out a piece between our fingers, and yank it out and make it stretch just a little closer to the finish line…..

Imagine a God who watches you go through that, knowing all the time He has the power to make it happen. Yet chooses not to.

A God who provides false hope is not a good God.

Given a choice between believing God is good, and God is in control, I have chosen to believe God is good. While believing in a predetermined path may provide us with some level of comfort, it also tends to make us abdicate responsibility for pride, unkindness, for a lack of mercy, and for an absence of compassion. Why help someone else who is predestined to fail?

All the opportunities God has set before you are real, and are always possible. He did not place that advertisement and always mean to hire someone else. The end is not predetermined, and all your successes and failures are not written in stone. You always have the power to change, to grow, to heal, to move, to hope and to love. God knows this about you. He knows you’re not always in control, but He trusts your heart. Do you believe the same about Him?


If you liked this post, you may also like

When Your Strengths Are Not Your Friend

4 thoughts on “Job Ads, False Hope, And Why God Isn’t In Control

  1. Very well said, Jo. You always write best when you write from your heart.

    I you were up for a theological discussion (which I love), then I’d assert that yes, He is in control, and that does not in any way conflict with the idea that things happen that are not His will. Our limited minds may not grasp how both of those can be true, but then again, I don’t grasp a lot of things that I know to be true, like gravity and combustion engines.

    More important than the theological discussion, of course, is your need for God to come through. I will pray. Keep us posted.

  2. “Praise be to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ! In his great mercy he has given us new birth into a living hope through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead, and into an inheritance that can never perish, spoil or fade – kept in heaven for you, who through faith are shielded by God’s power until the coming of the salvation that is ready to be revealed in the last time. In this you greatly rejoice, though now for a little while you may have had to suffer grief in all kinds of trials. These have come so that your faith – of greater worth than gold, which perishes even though refined by fire – may be proved genuine and may result in praise, glory and honor when Jesus Christ is revealed. Though you have not seen him, you love him; and even though you do not see him now, you believe in him and are filled with an inexpressible and glorious joy, for you are receiving the goal of your faith, the salvation of your souls.’ ~ 1 Peter 1:3-9

    ‘But do not forget this one thing, dear friends: With the Lord a day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years are like a day. The Lord is not slow in keeping his promise, as some understand slowness. He is patient with you, not wanting anyone to perish, but everyone to come to repentance.’ ~ 2 Peter 3:8-9

    Here are a few hidden gems of truth in His Word that speak of His ability to end suffering but choosing not to for the purpose of wanting more people to know about His gift of salvation… and why he lets us suffer when He really could end it.

    Keep reading God’s word Jo… and focus on Jesus who is not only good but perfect and also has been given authority over everything (Colossians and the beginning of Acts are great passages about this )… you really will be blessed by learning more about who God is by seeking Him out. <3

    1. What about this article makes you think that a few rote recitations of scripture will do here? The author has struggled and reached a conclusion, and to this you respond “well if you just read the New Testament a bit more, you’d understand…”

      Perhaps the answers are not as simple as you think?

You've heard my thoughts, now throw me yours...